- The best engineers I place aren't moving for money. Money came up as a reason to move on about 1 in 10 first calls this year.
- What they ask for is fair, not a jackpot. The typical ask was around 5% more.
- When they have more than one offer, they usually take the job they're most excited about. Within reason.
- Nobody takes a big pay cut for a nice mission statement. Be fair, be fast, be upfront. You don't need to win a bidding war.
"We'll just have to pay more"
Every founder who's lost an engineer at offer stage has said some version of this. Somebody else waved a bigger number, so the answer must be a bigger number.
Sometimes it is. Mostly it isn't. Which is good news, because most startups don't have a bigger number.
Software engineers are well paid for their years of experience. The ones purely chasing money have traditionally been able to find it, usually somewhere with a lanyard and a very large office canteen. I'm not sure that lasts forever if your skills don't match your number. Either way, those aren't the people early-stage startups are trying to hire.
In my experience, a wildly unrealistic salary expectation is one of the clearest signs someone doesn't really want to work at an early-stage startup. Or at least it's not top of their list. Which is fine. It's just useful to know on the first call rather than the fifth.
The engineers startups do want are the ones who like the work. Pay them fairly and the number stops being the main event. It just has to be fair.
It's almost never the salary
On a first call I always ask why someone's thinking about moving. Here's what came back this year, across engineers who went on to interview for roles at early-stage London startups.
Most people gave more than one reason, so this doesn't add up to 100%. "Money" counts anyone who mentioned pay as a reason at all, not just as the main one.
Ownership beat money by two to one. A better problem beat it too. Even "I'm being made redundant" came up more often than "I want to be paid more", which says something about this year. None of it says "please find me a recruiter who can get me 40% more". Shame, really. It would make my job a lot simpler.
"The most important is engineering culture. Then the salary range."
"I sort of want more ownership."
Fair, not a jackpot
When we get to pay, the ask is usually modest. The typical engineer wanted around 5% more than they were on. Not 30%. Five. Founders brace for a hostage negotiation and get a polite request for 5% and a decent laptop.
About 1 in 6 put it even more simply: whatever happens, no pay cut. Which is completely reasonable. Nobody wants to explain to their partner that they've taken a pay cut to work somewhere with a nicer logo.
Unless the logo comes with something. A few people this year happily took less: for fewer office days, a far more interesting problem, a proper chunk of equity, or because they'd just had a big rise and could afford to pick the job they actually wanted. That's not going backwards. That's buying something with the difference. Good call, all of them.
That's the line. Engineers will happily skip the biggest offer. They won't take a step down for nothing.
Then there's the other end. One engineer this year had landed a £60k rise by changing jobs. Six months later he was back on the market, looking for another £60k. I worked out fairly quickly that I wasn't the right person to help with that one. Genuinely, good luck to him. At that rate he'll be on a million by 2030.
They pick the one they can't stop thinking about
The engineers startups want rarely have one offer. By the time they're in a final round with you, they're often in a final round somewhere else too.
And when the offers land, they almost always go with the role they're more excited about, not the one with the biggest number on it. One engineer this year had two offers side by side and told me:
"On paper, the other one is better. But I kind of spent the whole weekend trying to justify to myself the one I wanted."
He took the one he wanted. On paper, the other one was better.
Within reason, though. If both offers are over £100k and the gap is £10k, £15k, even £20k, the role, the team and the company usually win. If the gap is £50k, the money wins. Fair enough. Enthusiasm doesn't pay a mortgage.
And there's always a point where it tips. Another engineer, mid-offer, said exactly what most people are thinking:
"This would be so much easier if they just matched my current base. I'd accept it already."
Not a bidding war. Not a jackpot. Just matched. They wanted the job. They needed the offer to stop being the thing they were thinking about.
It's usually not the base salary
When an engineer picks another offer over yours, the base salary gets the blame. Look a bit closer and it's usually something else.
- Office days. Five days in versus two is worth a lot of money to someone with a 75-minute commute. More than most founders think.
- Equity they can't make sense of. An option grant with no strike price, no vesting detail and "we'll sort the paperwork later" is worth roughly nothing in a candidate's head.
- Speed. The company that made an offer on Thursday beats the one still booking a final round for next week. Nobody has ever said "I'll wait for the slow one, they seemed thorough."
- Stability. After a year of redundancies, plenty of engineers will take a bit less for somewhere that feels like it'll still be there next summer.
None of those are fixed by adding £10k. All of them can be fixed before the offer goes out, and most of them are free.
Be fair, be fast, be upfront
- Pay fairly for the level. Not top of market. Fair. If you're well under, no amount of mission will close that gap.
- Get the number out early. The range on the first call saves everyone a month, and saves you a very awkward final round.
- Explain the equity properly. How many options, what percentage, strike, vesting, what happens if they leave. In writing.
- Say the office days on day one. Not at offer stage. Day one.
- Sell the job. The thing that beats a bigger offer is an engineer who can't stop thinking about your problem. Tell them what they'll own and why it's hard.
Doubling the salary also works. We just haven't met many seed-stage startups who want to do that.
Know your number. Then stop thinking about it.
Work out what "fair" is for you before the process starts: the number you'd be happy with, and the one you won't go below. Then spend the rest of the process working out whether you actually want the job.
Because the people I've seen happiest a year in aren't the ones who squeezed out the last £5k. They're the ones who picked the problem they wanted to work on. The extra £5k went on a sofa. They can't remember which one.
It was never about the money
Good engineers aren't mercenaries. They'll walk past a bigger number for better work, more ownership or a team they rate. They just won't walk backwards for nothing.
So pay them fairly, tell them everything early, and make the job the most interesting thing they've been offered. That's the whole trick. As tricks go, it's a cheap one.
Figures come from first calls and offer conversations with engineers interviewing at early-stage London startups we worked with between January and October 2026. Quotes are anonymised and lightly trimmed. Nothing here identifies a company or a candidate.
